Best Muse Album - Page 7

_Ed_ · 12-09-2009, 12:51 PM

For me:

1. OOS
2. Black Holes & Revelations
3. The Resistance
(reasonably big gap)
4. Absolution
5. Showbiz

Really nothing between the first three though. And I'm not knocking the other two either - both have several songs I love on them.

Green Mamba · 12-09-2009, 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LTM

BH&R not popular then? Wow.

I must say it has some incredible tracks on it. Take A Bow is my most played Muse record ever. City Of Delusion is phenomenal, Starlight and SMBH are two of their biggest commercial successes and Knights of Cydonia will probably be forever more the mainstay of Muse's sets... but at the same time the album does have some dross. More than ever is the description "A handful of bangers and the rest fillers' apt... But I feel the strongest songs on a commercial tip are from this album. This is why I believe even far into the future, this album will feature strongly in all live Muse sets.

I suspect its going to come at a lot of peoples last choice. For me it's some of the most Creative work they have done as musicians as individual songs, MOTP, COD, excellent. But as an Album the weakest album they have done.

Absolution is a journey from start to end. It is such a strong album, even with the straight forward songs such a TSP or TOADA.

I would be very happy not to hear starlight on the setlist. The very fact there are commercialy known songs is the Influence of Warner who have no influence on Live tours.

Give me Dead Star Of Fury any day in such songs like that.

1 Absolution / Resistance (Can't make my mind up ATM)
2 OOS
3 BHAR
4 Showbiz

Mozza · 12-09-2009, 01:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Mamba

I suspect its going to come at a lot of peoples last choice. For me it's some of the most Creative work they have done as musicians as individual songs, MOTP, COD, excellent. But as an Album the weakest album they have done.

It's far more of a creative attempt than say Origin of Symmetry (which is my favourite Muse album), but as an album it bombs, because there's one thing with being creative, its an entirely another thing to make it work, and I just don't feel Black Holes and Revelations has any flow or any common ground which make all the tracks feel like part of an album.

RazzGirl · 12-09-2009, 02:14 PM

Too hard to choose!!! I'd say the first two are a joint first.. cant decide!!

1. Absolution
2. The Resistance
3. Origin of Symmetry
4. Showbiz
5. Black holes and Revelations

Forwen · 12-09-2009, 03:38 PM

1. Origin
2. Absolution
3. BH&R
4. Showbiz
5. Hullabaloo (I'm including this too as I prefer listening to the b-sides more than most of Resistance)

6. Resistance

lukeskymac · 12-09-2009, 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Mamba

I suspect its going to come at a lot of peoples last choice. For me it's some of the most Creative work they have done as musicians as individual songs, MOTP, COD, excellent. But as an Album the weakest album they have done.

Absolution is a journey from start to end. It is such a strong album, even with the straight forward songs such a TSP or TOADA.

I would be very happy not to hear starlight on the setlist. The very fact there are commercialy known songs is the Influence of Warner who have no influence on Live tours.

Give me Dead Star Of Fury any day in such songs like that.

1 Absolution / Resistance (Can't make my mind up ATM)
2 OOS
3 BHAR
4 Showbiz

BHaR has many great songs, but it simply doesn't work as an album like the others. The Resistance flows exceptionally well, and that's why it stole the crown from OoS for me. Although that gap (the song quality one) between them is growing for me... Slowly, but it is...

lukeskymac · 12-09-2009, 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Forwen

1. Origin
2. Absolution
3. BH&R
4. Showbiz
5. Hullabaloo (I'm including this too as I prefer listening to the b-sides more than most of Resistance)

6. Resistance

You're insane

ronaldo789 · 12-09-2009, 03:51 PM

WTF how has BH&R only got 9 votes?

Raiko · 12-09-2009, 04:05 PM

It's my 2nd favourite album so I couldn't vote for it.

Priad-Luabe · 12-09-2009, 04:09 PM

the resistance, not just the best muse album, but imho the best album ever created

Tokamak · 12-09-2009, 04:21 PM

1. Absolution
2. The Resistance
3. Showbiz
4. OOS
5. BHAR

Priad-Luabe · 12-09-2009, 04:24 PM

1) The Resistance
2) Bh&R
3) Absolution
4) OoS
5) Showbiz

Forwen · 12-09-2009, 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lukeskymac

You're insane

Well yes, maybe. I do seem to see things (or hear things in this case) differently to other people most of the time.

Caff · 12-09-2009, 04:25 PM

BHAR disappointed me. It has a couple of my favourite Muse tracks on it but as an album it's just a bit "meh" for me. Full of too many ideas that don't seem to go in the direction they were aiming for. I find I skip the majority of that album.

But what do I know? One of my favourite tracks is Hoodoo and lots of people hate that one

So yeah BHAR is definitely my least favourite and I consider it their weakest.

Mozza · 12-09-2009, 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caff

BHAR disappointed me. It has a couple of my favourite Muse tracks on it but as an album it's just a bit "meh" for me. Full of too many ideas that don't seem to go in the direction they were aiming for. I find I skip the majority of that album.

But what do I know? One of my favourite tracks is Hoodoo and lots of people hate that one

So yeah BHAR is definitely my least favourite and I consider it their weakest.

My favourites on BHaR are Hoodoo, City of Delusion and Take a Bow in that order.

The opening paragraph of my review of The Resistance sums up my feelings of BHaR really.

View Poll Results: What Is Your Favourite Muse Album?
Showbiz	61	4.15%
Origin of Symmetry	613	41.67%
Absolution	453	30.80%
Black Holes & Revelations	160	10.88%
The Resistance	184	12.51%
Voters: 1471. You may not vote on this poll

12-09-2009, 02:14 PM	#94
RazzGirl :) Join Date: 02 June 2007 Location: London Age: 30	Too hard to choose!!! I'd say the first two are a joint first.. cant decide!! 1. Absolution 2. The Resistance 3. Origin of Symmetry 4. Showbiz 5. Black holes and Revelations __________________ <17/06/07 - Wembley Stadium> <05/09/09 - The Den> <13/11/09 - O2 Arena><11/09/10 - Wembley Stadium>

12-09-2009, 04:05 PM	#99
Raiko Occupation: Loser Join Date: 08 August 2006 Location: Luton, UK Age: 31	It's my 2nd favourite album so I couldn't vote for it. __________________ "Lips are turning blue. A kiss that can't renew. I only dream of you. My beautiful." - Sing for Absolution "Please don't break my ideals, and say what's fake was always real." - Shine "I have had recurring nightmares that I was loved for who I am and missed the opportunity to be a better man." - Hoodoo "Take off your disguise. I know that underneath its me." - Megalomania

12-09-2009, 04:25 PM	#104
Caff Tart of Pleasure Lifetime Achiever Award Best Muser Couple 2013, 2014 Join Date: 08 March 2003 Location: Arkham Asylum Age: 32	BHAR disappointed me. It has a couple of my favourite Muse tracks on it but as an album it's just a bit "meh" for me. Full of too many ideas that don't seem to go in the direction they were aiming for. I find I skip the majority of that album. But what do I know? One of my favourite tracks is Hoodoo and lots of people hate that one So yeah BHAR is definitely my least favourite and I consider it their weakest. __________________ Who wants some of my chair?! Back aff ya spooky bitch!

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

12-09-2009, 12:51 PM	#91
_Ed_ Moa Join Date: 28 July 2004 Location: Marsden Bay, NZ Age: 31	For me: 1. OOS 2. Black Holes & Revelations 3. The Resistance (reasonably big gap) 4. Absolution 5. Showbiz Really nothing between the first three though. And I'm not knocking the other two either - both have several songs I love on them.

12-09-2009, 03:38 PM	#95
Forwen Slave to the grave Join Date: 14 October 2006 Location: North Northumberland. UK Age: 49	1. Origin 2. Absolution 3. BH&R 4. Showbiz 5. Hullabaloo (I'm including this too as I prefer listening to the b-sides more than most of Resistance) 6. Resistance

12-09-2009, 03:51 PM	#98
ronaldo789 Member Join Date: 12 September 2009	WTF how has BH&R only got 9 votes?

12-09-2009, 04:21 PM	#101
Tokamak Banned Join Date: 15 March 2005 Age: 30	1. Absolution 2. The Resistance 3. Showbiz 4. OOS 5. BHAR

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)